Windsurf
realtime
User Presence Showing Wrong Online/Offline Status in Windsurf App
The user presence system in your Windsurf-generated app shows incorrect online/offline status. Users who closed the app hours ago still appear as online, users who are actively using the app show as offline, or presence status flickers between online and offline rapidly.
Presence tracking is crucial for chat apps, collaborative tools, and social features. When it's unreliable, users send messages to people who aren't there, miss that collaborators are available, or lose trust in the application's real-time features.
The issue often manifests differently across browsers and devices — a user may appear online in their own browser but offline to everyone else, or vice versa. Mobile users are particularly affected because their connections are frequently interrupted.
Error Messages You Might See
User shows online but is unreachable
Presence flickers between online and offline
last_seen: 3 hours ago but status: online
Offline event received after new online event
Multiple presence entries for same user
Common Causes
- No heartbeat mechanism — Presence is set to online on connect and offline on disconnect, but disconnection events are unreliable and can be missed
- Stale presence data — The presence status is stored in the database but never expires, so users who disconnect abnormally stay online forever
- Tab/window handling — Opening multiple tabs creates multiple connections, and closing one tab sets the user offline even though other tabs are open
- Network interruption not detected — Mobile connections drop frequently but the server doesn't detect the disconnection for minutes due to TCP keepalive delays
- Race conditions on connect/disconnect — When a user reconnects quickly, the offline event from the old connection arrives after the online event from the new connection
How to Fix It
- Implement heartbeat-based presence — Send a heartbeat from the client every 15-30 seconds. On the server, mark users as offline if no heartbeat is received for 2x the interval
- Use Redis with TTL for presence — Store presence in Redis with a 60-second TTL. Each heartbeat refreshes the TTL. When the TTL expires, the user is automatically offline
- Handle multiple tabs/windows — Track connection count per user. Only set offline when the count reaches zero. Increment on connect, decrement on disconnect
- Add last_seen timestamp — Instead of binary online/offline, store a last_seen timestamp and consider users online if seen within the last 60 seconds
- Debounce status changes — When a user goes offline, wait 5-10 seconds before broadcasting the offline status. If they reconnect in that window, cancel the offline broadcast
- Broadcast presence updates efficiently — Use Socket.io rooms or pub/sub to only notify users who are viewing the presence indicator, not all connected users
Real developers can help you.
Milan Surelia
Milan Surelia is a Mobile App Developer with 5+ years of experience crafting scalable, cross-platform apps at 7Span and Meticha. At 7Span, he engineers feature-rich Flutter apps with smooth performance and modern UI. As the Co-Founder of Meticha, he builds open-source tools and developer-focused products that solve real-world problems.
Expertise:
💡 Developing cross-platform apps using Flutter, Dart, and Jetpack Compose for Android, iOS, and Web.
🖋️ Sharing insights through technical writing, blogging, and open-source contributions.
🤝 Collaborating closely with designers, PMs, and developers to build seamless mobile experiences.
Notable Achievements:
🎯 Revamped the Vepaar app into Vepaar Store & CRM with a 2x performance boost and smoother UX.
🚀 Launched Compose101 — a Jetpack Compose starter kit to speed up Android development.
🌟 Open source contributions on Github & StackOverflow for Flutter & Dart
🎖️ Worked on improving app performance and user experience with smart solutions.
Milan is always happy to connect, work on new ideas, and explore the latest in technology.
Bastien Labelle
Full stack dev w/ 20+ years of experience
Taufan
I’m a product-focused engineer and tech leader who builds scalable systems and turns ideas into production-ready platforms.
Over the past years, I’ve worked across startups and fast-moving teams, leading backend architecture, improving system reliability, and shipping products used by thousands of users. My strength is not just writing code — but connecting product vision, technical execution, and business impact.
Simon A.
I'm a backend developer building APIs, emulators, and interactive game systems. Professionally, I've developed Java/Spring reporting solutions, managed relational and NoSQL databases, and implemented CI/CD workflows.
Omar Faruk
As a Product Engineer at Klasio, I contributed to end-to-end product development, focusing on scalability, performance, and user experience.
My work spanned building and refining core features, developing dynamic website templates, integrating secure and reliable payment gateways, and optimizing the overall system architecture.
I played a key role in creating a scalable and maintainable platform to support educators and learners globally.
I'm enthusiastic about embracing new challenges and making meaningful contributions.
Jared Hasson
Full time lead founding dev at a cyber security saas startup, with 10 yoe and a bachelor's in CS. Building & debugging software products is what I've spent my time on for forever
Caio Rodrigues
I'm a full-stack developer focused on building practical and scalable web applications. My main experience is with **React, TypeScript, and modern frontend architectures**, where I prioritize clean code, component reusability, and maintainable project structures.
I have strong experience working with **dynamic forms, state management (Redux / React Hook Form), and complex data-driven interfaces**. I enjoy solving real-world problems by turning ideas into reliable software that companies can actually use in their daily operations.
Beyond coding, I care about **software quality and architecture**, following best practices for componentization, code organization, and performance optimization.
I'm also comfortable working across the stack when needed, integrating APIs, handling business logic, and helping transform prototypes into production-ready systems.
My goal is always to deliver solutions that are **simple, efficient, and genuinely useful for the people using them.**
Antriksh Narang
5 years+ Experienced Dev (Specially in Web Development), can help in python, javascript, react, next.js and full stack web dev technologies.
Anthony Akpan
Developer with 8 years of experience building softwares fro startups
Alvin Voo
I’ve watched the tech landscape evolve over the last decade—from the structured days of Java Server Pages to the current "wild west" of Agentic-driven development. While AI can "vibe" a frontend into existence, I specialize in the architecture that keeps it from collapsing.
My expertise lies in the critical backend infrastructure: the parts that must be fast, secure, and scalable. I thrive on high-pressure environments, such as when I had only three weeks to architect and launch an Ethereum redemption system with minimal prior crypto knowledge, turning it into a major revenue stream.
What I bring to your project:
Forensic Debugging: I don't just "patch" bugs; I use tools like Datadog and Explain Analyzers to map out bottlenecks and resolve root causes—like significantly reducing memory usage by optimizing complex DB joins.
Full-Stack Context: Deep experience in Node.js and React, ensuring backends play perfectly with mobile and web teams.
Sanity in the Age of AI: I bridge the gap between "best practices" and modern speed, ensuring your project isn't just built fast, but built to last.
You don't need to be technical. Just describe what's wrong and a verified developer will handle the rest.
Get HelpFrequently Asked Questions
How often should presence heartbeats be sent?
Every 15-30 seconds is typical. Shorter intervals detect disconnections faster but increase server load. Set the offline threshold to 2x the heartbeat interval (e.g., heartbeat every 20s, offline after 40s of no heartbeat).
Should I store presence in the database or Redis?
Use Redis. Presence data changes constantly and needs TTL-based expiration. Storing it in your main database creates unnecessary write load. Redis keys with TTL naturally expire, handling abnormal disconnections automatically.