Windsurf
realtime
User Presence Showing Wrong Online/Offline Status in Windsurf App
The user presence system in your Windsurf-generated app shows incorrect online/offline status. Users who closed the app hours ago still appear as online, users who are actively using the app show as offline, or presence status flickers between online and offline rapidly.
Presence tracking is crucial for chat apps, collaborative tools, and social features. When it's unreliable, users send messages to people who aren't there, miss that collaborators are available, or lose trust in the application's real-time features.
The issue often manifests differently across browsers and devices — a user may appear online in their own browser but offline to everyone else, or vice versa. Mobile users are particularly affected because their connections are frequently interrupted.
Error Messages You Might See
User shows online but is unreachable
Presence flickers between online and offline
last_seen: 3 hours ago but status: online
Offline event received after new online event
Multiple presence entries for same user
Common Causes
- No heartbeat mechanism — Presence is set to online on connect and offline on disconnect, but disconnection events are unreliable and can be missed
- Stale presence data — The presence status is stored in the database but never expires, so users who disconnect abnormally stay online forever
- Tab/window handling — Opening multiple tabs creates multiple connections, and closing one tab sets the user offline even though other tabs are open
- Network interruption not detected — Mobile connections drop frequently but the server doesn't detect the disconnection for minutes due to TCP keepalive delays
- Race conditions on connect/disconnect — When a user reconnects quickly, the offline event from the old connection arrives after the online event from the new connection
How to Fix It
- Implement heartbeat-based presence — Send a heartbeat from the client every 15-30 seconds. On the server, mark users as offline if no heartbeat is received for 2x the interval
- Use Redis with TTL for presence — Store presence in Redis with a 60-second TTL. Each heartbeat refreshes the TTL. When the TTL expires, the user is automatically offline
- Handle multiple tabs/windows — Track connection count per user. Only set offline when the count reaches zero. Increment on connect, decrement on disconnect
- Add last_seen timestamp — Instead of binary online/offline, store a last_seen timestamp and consider users online if seen within the last 60 seconds
- Debounce status changes — When a user goes offline, wait 5-10 seconds before broadcasting the offline status. If they reconnect in that window, cancel the offline broadcast
- Broadcast presence updates efficiently — Use Socket.io rooms or pub/sub to only notify users who are viewing the presence indicator, not all connected users
Real developers can help you.
MFox
Full-stack professional senior engineer (15+years). Extensive experience in software development, qa, and IP networking.
Simon A.
I'm a backend developer building APIs, emulators, and interactive game systems. Professionally, I've developed Java/Spring reporting solutions, managed relational and NoSQL databases, and implemented CI/CD workflows.
AUXLE
I am a Full Stack Developer experienced in building Websites, Web apps and Cross Platform Mobile Apps for Startups and Companies.
Basel Issmail
’m a Senior Full-Stack Developer and Tech Lead with experience designing and building scalable web platforms. I work across the full development lifecycle, from translating business requirements into technical architecture to delivering reliable production systems.
My work focuses on modern web technologies, including TypeScript, Angular, Node.js, and cloud-based architectures. I enjoy solving complex technical problems and helping teams turn product ideas and prototypes into working platforms that can grow and scale.
In addition to development, I often collaborate closely with product managers, business analysts, designers, and QA teams to ensure that solutions align with both technical and business goals.
I enjoy working with startups and product teams where I can contribute both as a hands-on engineer and as a technical partner in designing and delivering impactful software.
Taufan
I’m a product-focused engineer and tech leader who builds scalable systems and turns ideas into production-ready platforms.
Over the past years, I’ve worked across startups and fast-moving teams, leading backend architecture, improving system reliability, and shipping products used by thousands of users. My strength is not just writing code — but connecting product vision, technical execution, and business impact.
Richard McSorley
Full-Stack Software Engineer with 8+ years building high-performance applications for enterprise clients. Shipped production systems at Walmart (4,000+ stores), Cigna (20M+ users), and Arkansas Blue Cross. 5 patents in retail/supply chain tech. Currently focused on AI integrations, automation tools, and TypeScript-first architectures.
Stanislav Prigodich
15+ years building iOS and web apps at startups and enterprise companies. I want to use that experience to help builders ship real products - when something breaks, I'm here to fix it.
zipking
I am a technologist and product builder dedicated to creating high-impact solutions at the intersection of AI and specialized markets. Currently, I am focused on PropScan (EstateGuard), an AI-driven SaaS platform tailored for the Japanese real estate industry, and exploring the potential of Archify.
As an INFJ-T, I approach development with a "systems-thinking" mindset—balancing technical precision with a deep understanding of user needs. I particularly enjoy the challenge of architecting Vertical AI SaaS and optimizing Small Language Models (SLMs) to solve specific, real-world business problems. Whether I'm in a CTO-level leadership role or hands-on with the code, I thrive on building tools that turn complex data into actionable value.
Tejas Chokhawala
Full-stack engineer with 5 years experience building production web apps using React, Next.js and TypeScript.
Focused on performance, clean architecture and shipping fast.
Experienced with Supabase/Postgres backends, Stripe billing, and building AI-assisted developer tools.
Prakash Prajapati
I’m a Senior Python Developer specializing in building secure, scalable, and highly available systems. I work primarily with Python, Django, FastAPI, Docker, PostgreSQL, and modern AI tooling such as PydanticAI, focusing on clean architecture, strong design principles, and reliable DevOps practices. I enjoy solving complex engineering problems and designing systems that are maintainable, resilient, and built to scale.
You don't need to be technical. Just describe what's wrong and a verified developer will handle the rest.
Get HelpFrequently Asked Questions
How often should presence heartbeats be sent?
Every 15-30 seconds is typical. Shorter intervals detect disconnections faster but increase server load. Set the offline threshold to 2x the heartbeat interval (e.g., heartbeat every 20s, offline after 40s of no heartbeat).
Should I store presence in the database or Redis?
Use Redis. Presence data changes constantly and needs TTL-based expiration. Storing it in your main database creates unnecessary write load. Redis keys with TTL naturally expire, handling abnormal disconnections automatically.